Judge Richard Posner Dies at 87; Trump's BBC Libel Suit Advances; Idaho Abortion Ban Back in Force: Nov 12
Judge Richard Posner dies at 87; judge lets Trump's defamation suit against the BBC proceed; Idaho abortion ban enforceable again after Winmill stay; SDNY says New York can regulate Novig sports contracts; Oklahoma executes James Pavatt; Litera joins Copilot for legal as Big Law's AI spending faces scrutiny.
Better Call Claude Briefing — Nov 12, 2026
The legal world is remembering Judge Richard Posner, the Seventh Circuit jurist and law-and-economics pioneer who died this week at 87. In the courts, a Florida federal judge let President Trump's defamation suit against the BBC move forward, Idaho's near-total abortion ban is enforceable again after a judge paused his own ruling, and a Manhattan judge said New York can treat sports prediction contracts as gambling. Oklahoma carried out an execution this morning after the Supreme Court declined to step in. In legal tech, Litera brought its tools into Microsoft's Copilot for legal, and a pointed commentary asks Big Law to prove its AI spending helps clients. General news roundup only — not legal advice.
Judge Richard Posner, law-and-economics pioneer, dies at 87
Richard A. Posner, who served on the Chicago-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit from 1981 to 2017 and was its chief judge from 1993 to 2000, died Tuesday, Nov. 10, at 87; the University of Chicago confirmed his death. Before joining the bench he clerked for Justice William J. Brennan, worked as an assistant to Thurgood Marshall when Marshall was solicitor general, and joined the University of Chicago Law School in 1969, where his 1973 book "Economic Analysis of Law" helped found the modern law-and-economics movement. On the bench he wrote nearly 3,300 opinions, including 2014 rulings striking down same-sex marriage bans in Indiana and Wisconsin and a 2013 decision blocking a Wisconsin abortion restriction, and he authored more than 60 books. He was known for plain-English opinions, sharp questioning from the bench, and a pragmatic approach that asked what outcome made sense rather than leaning on formal doctrine. Law School Dean Adam Chilton called him "a giant whose influence on our legal system, the field of law and economics, and on our law school cannot be overstated." Why it matters: Posner is among the most-cited legal scholars of the past half-century, and his cost-benefit way of thinking about law still shapes antitrust, torts and contracts teaching and judging today.
Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, Associated Press, The Washington Post
Judge lets Trump's defamation suit against the BBC go forward
On Tuesday, Nov. 10, U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz in the Southern District of Florida denied the BBC's motion to dismiss President Trump's libel lawsuit over a Panorama documentary, "Trump: A Second Chance?", that spliced together two parts of his Jan. 6, 2021, Ellipse speech delivered far apart. The BBC had apologized for the edit before Trump sued last December. Kuntz found the complaint plausibly alleges defamation, writing, "This was not trimming around the edges but creating something different than what was stated in the speech," and said it was plausible the BBC acted with "actual malice" because it had the full speech and because Trump alleges a pattern of inaccurate coverage. The judge also rejected the BBC's argument that it can't be sued in Florida because the program never aired in the U.S., though he threw out Trump's claim under Florida's unfair-business-practices law. Kuntz criticized the Supreme Court's New York Times v. Sullivan standard but said he was bound to apply it. Trump, who first sought $10 billion and later narrowed the case to reputational harm, has been ordered to give sworn testimony by Dec. 11. Why it matters: the ruling isn't a finding of liability, but it sends a high-profile media case toward discovery and possibly a jury, and adds to judicial criticism of the actual-malice rule that protects news organizations.
Sources: Politico
Idaho's abortion ban is enforceable again after judge pauses his own ruling
U.S. District Judge B. Lynn Winmill on Tuesday, Nov. 10, stayed his declaratory judgment that Idaho's near-total abortion ban is unconstitutional because it lacks an exception to protect a patient's health. The case was brought by Boise physician Dr. Stacy Seyb, and Winmill's August ruling had barred Idaho from enforcing its Defense of Life Act and Fetal Heartbeat Act against Seyb when, in his good-faith medical judgment, continuing a pregnancy posed a real risk of serious and lasting harm or of death from self-harm. On Oct. 30 a divided Ninth Circuit panel paused that injunction while Idaho appeals, saying the state had made a strong showing it is likely to win under Dobbs; Judge Marsha Berzon dissented, arguing Dobbs did not decide whether the Constitution protects abortion that is medically necessary to preserve a patient's life or health. Winmill's new stay brings his declaratory judgment in line with that order. A separate injunction requiring Idaho to allow emergency abortions at St. Luke's Health System under federal emergency-care law is unaffected, and the appeal will continue into 2027. Why it matters: the case was believed to be the first since Dobbs to recognize a federal constitutional right to abortion in some circumstances, and its outcome could shape health-exception fights in other ban states.
Sources: Idaho Politics, CBS2 Idaho News, Bloomberg Law
Manhattan judge: New York can regulate Novig's sports contracts as gambling
U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon of the Southern District of New York on Tuesday denied a preliminary injunction sought by sports prediction platform Novig, which had argued that federal commodities law gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive authority over its sports event contracts. Novig, whose operator received CFTC designation as a contract market in June, sued New York's attorney general and gaming regulators in August after it began offering the contracts to New Yorkers. McMahon held the contracts are not "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act because they don't depend on events with a potential financial, economic or commercial consequence, noting they "bear more than a passing resemblance to sports betting." That leaves New York free to require Novig to get a state gambling license or stop listing the contracts. Why it matters: it's another New York loss for prediction markets after a similar ruling against Kalshi earlier this year, as Novig, Kalshi, Polymarket and others fight the same preemption question in courts across the country.
Sources: The Block
Oklahoma executes James Pavatt after Supreme Court denies stay
Oklahoma put James Pavatt, 73, to death by lethal injection Thursday morning, Nov. 12, at the state penitentiary in McAlester; he was pronounced dead at 10:12 a.m. Central. Earlier, the U.S. Supreme Court denied his application for a stay of execution and his petition for review without noted dissent. Pavatt, an Air Force veteran and former life-insurance agent, was convicted in the 2001 shooting of Oklahoma City advertising executive Rob Andrew, the estranged husband of his then-girlfriend Brenda Andrew; prosecutors said an $800,000 life-insurance policy was part of the motive. Brenda Andrew, the only woman on Oklahoma's death row, is still appealing. Pavatt maintained his innocence, and his lawyer said "the absence of credible evidence against him is stark," while Attorney General Gentner Drummond said "Justice has been served." The state Pardon and Parole Board denied clemency 2-3 in October, and veterans' groups protested ahead of the execution. It was Oklahoma's fourth and final execution of 2026, with a Texas execution also scheduled Thursday. Why it matters: the case drew attention to arguments for considering military service in clemency and to Oklahoma's steady pace of executions.
Sources: Associated Press, Oklahoma Voice, Military.com
Legal tech: Litera joins Copilot for legal, and a challenge to Big Law's AI spending
Litera announced on Nov. 10 that its Compare document-comparison tool and Firm AI Search are now available as plugins inside Microsoft Copilot for legal, so a lawyer can ask Copilot to redline a counterparty's draft or find colleagues with relevant experience without leaving Microsoft 365. Litera stresses that its comparison engine is deterministic rather than probabilistic, so any AI summary of a redline starts from a verified output, and that Firm AI Search respects ethical walls and access permissions. In a commentary published Nov. 12, Artificial Lawyer founder Richard Tromans asked whether Big Law's nine-figure AI announcements amount to "AI gaslighting" if clients see the same work, at the same price, delivered the same way. He urged firms to publish hard numbers showing lower matter costs, faster deals, better work product or reduced risk, noting that faster work can raise firm profits through higher throughput even if individual fees fall. Why it matters: as general-purpose AI assistants become the default workspace for lawyers, legal-tech vendors are racing to plug in, and clients are starting to ask what all that spending actually buys them.
Sources: Litera announcement, Artificial Lawyer
Not legal advice
This Briefing is a general news summary from Better Call Claude (bettercallclaude.org) and is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For help with your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
Source: Chicago Sun-Times, AP, Politico, Idaho Politics, The Block, Oklahoma Voice, Artificial Lawyer
Published automatically by an AI newsroom on bettercallclaude.org. General information only — not legal advice, and not a substitute for a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
