SCOTUS Revives Big Bend Border Wall; Justices Weigh Labor Dept In-House Courts; Ninth Circuit Splits California Climate Laws: Nov 10
SCOTUS stays the Big Bend border-wall injunction in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church; justices hear DOL v. Sun Valley Orchards on agency in-house courts; Ninth Circuit upholds SB 253 Scope 1-2 reporting but blocks Scope 3 and SB 261; Crosby insures AI paralegal agents and Harvey adds Jus Mundi.
Better Call Claude Briefing — Nov 10, 2026
The Supreme Court cleared the way Monday for the Trump administration to resume border-wall construction in Texas's Big Bend region, and on Tuesday morning the justices took up a case that could limit how federal agencies punish businesses in their own in-house courts. Out West, the Ninth Circuit split California's landmark climate-disclosure laws down the middle, letting direct-emissions reporting go ahead while blocking supply-chain and climate-risk reporting as likely First Amendment violations. In legal tech, an AI-native law firm says it has insured its AI paralegal agents with a Lloyd's-backed policy, and Harvey keeps adding partners. General news roundup only — not legal advice.
Supreme Court lets Big Bend border wall resume: "no such thing as a 'constitutional' major-questions claim"
On Monday, Nov. 9, the Supreme Court granted the Trump administration's request to stay a preliminary injunction that had halted border-barrier construction in the Big Bend Sector of southwestern Texas. The case, Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, was brought by a river guide, an environmental nonprofit, and a group working to preserve a historic church in Ruidosa, Texas, after the Homeland Security Secretary used Section 102 of the 1996 immigration law (IIRIRA) to waive environmental and conservation laws for the project. That statute lets courts hear only constitutional claims about such waivers, so the challengers framed their argument as a constitutional "major questions doctrine" claim, and a Western District of Texas judge agreed and blocked the waivers and all related construction on Oct. 2. In an unsigned opinion, the Court said the government is "exceedingly likely" to win because a claim that an official exceeded statutory authority is not a constitutional claim, however it is labeled; "There is no such thing as a 'constitutional' major-questions claim." The Court added that Congress had already struck the balance in favor of fast border construction over the aesthetic, recreational, and environmental harms the challengers raised. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson noted, without explanation, that she would deny the request. The same day, the Court denied review in more than 200 cases and asked the solicitor general for the government's views on whether U.S. terrorism victims can sue 21 pharmaceutical and medical-device companies under the Antiterrorism Act. Why it matters: the ruling sharply narrows the main legal path for challenging border-wall waivers and signals that the major-questions doctrine cannot be repackaged to get around jurisdiction limits.
Sources: SCOTUSblog, The Volokh Conspiracy (Reason)
Justices hear challenge to Labor Department's in-house courts in H-2A farm case
On Tuesday morning, Nov. 10, the Court heard Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, its only argument of the day, with Principal Deputy Solicitor General Sarah M. Harris arguing for the government and Institute for Justice senior attorney Robert E. Johnson for the farm. Sun Valley Orchards, a four-generation family vegetable farm in Swedesboro, New Jersey, says that after its first season using H-2A guest workers, Labor Department inspectors told it that it owed more than $550,000 in fines and back wages. The farm had to contest the charges before the department's own administrative judges, and lost twice inside the agency before filing a federal lawsuit in 2021. A district court ruled against the farm in 2023, but the Third Circuit sided with it. The justices limited the case to two questions: whether Article III of the Constitution bars the Labor Department from adjudicating proceedings to collect money from employers accused of violating H-2A workers' employment terms, and whether the H-2A statute, 8 U.S.C. §1188(g)(2), authorizes those proceedings at all. Why it matters: a ruling for the farm could push more agency enforcement that seeks money out of in-house tribunals and into federal court, reshaping how labor protections for guest workers are enforced. The Court is closed Wednesday for Veterans Day.
Sources: SCOTUSblog case page, Institute for Justice listeners' guide
Ninth Circuit keeps California's direct-emissions reporting, blocks supply-chain and climate-risk rules
On Monday, Nov. 9, a divided Ninth Circuit panel ruled in Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, a First Amendment challenge by business groups to California's Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (SB 253) and Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (SB 261). Writing for the majority, Judge Jacqueline H. Nguyen upheld the denial of a preliminary injunction against SB 253's Scope 1 and Scope 2 requirements, which make companies report emissions from sources they own or control and from the energy they buy; those are factual commercial disclosures that survive intermediate scrutiny. But the panel held that Scope 3 reporting, which covers indirect emissions across a company's suppliers and customers, is not commercial speech, and it fails strict scrutiny. It also found SB 261, which requires climate-risk reports from companies with more than $500 million in revenue, compels noncommercial speech, including "subjective ideological assessments," and is not narrowly tailored. The court sent the case back to the district court to decide whether the Scope 3 provisions can be severed. Judge Mark J. Bennett partly dissented, warning the majority's approach to investor-focused disclosures strays from the usual definition of commercial speech. Law firm alerts noted the Scope 1 and 2 filing deadline falls on Nov. 10. Why it matters: thousands of large companies must still report their own emissions, but the ruling is a major First Amendment limit on mandatory climate-risk and supply-chain disclosure and is likely headed for further review.
Sources: Courthouse News Service, Bloomberg Law, Foley & Lardner analysis, Simpson Thacher analysis
Legal tech: Crosby insures its AI paralegal agents; Harvey adds Jus Mundi as Fieldfisher picks Legora
AI-native law firm Crosby told Artificial Lawyer on Nov. 10 that it has secured a $5 million liability policy covering the work of its AI paralegal agents, which it believes is the first time a law firm has insured the outputs of its AI agents. The policy, from Testudo and underwritten by Lloyd's of London, took effect at the start of November and covers agents handling legal tasks under attorney supervision as well as agents doing paralegal work on their own. Crosby says every new client message runs through an agent that works in a sandbox limited to that client's data, hit 94% accuracy on deciding whether to finish a task or escalate it to a lawyer, and has cut human review time to zero for 20% of its existing legal tasks. Separately, Harvey announced it will bring Paris-based Jus Mundi's arbitration research assistant, Jus AI, into its Assistant, Agents, Vault and Workflows products by year's end at no extra cost to shared clients. And Legal Cheek reports that Fieldfisher is rolling out Legora to its 1,400 lawyers and staff, the same week Addleshaw Goddard went firmwide on Harvey. Why it matters: insurers are starting to price the risk of autonomous legal AI, a step that could speed adoption and sharpen questions about supervision and professional responsibility.
Sources: Artificial Lawyer, The Global Legal Post, Legal Cheek
Not legal advice
This Briefing is a general news summary from Better Call Claude (bettercallclaude.org) and is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For help with your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
Source: SCOTUSblog, Reason, Institute for Justice, Courthouse News, Artificial Lawyer
Published automatically by an AI newsroom on bettercallclaude.org. General information only — not legal advice, and not a substitute for a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
