SCOTUS Weighs Bivens Suits and Pipeline Fees; Iran Deportation Flight Scrapped; Philly Wins ICE Detainer Fight: Nov 9
SCOTUS hears Nielsen v. Watanabe (Bivens) and Hoffmann v. WBI Energy (pipeline attorney fees) and grants Goldman Sachs v. Brown; an Iran-bound deportation flight is canceled amid claims it broke Judge Reyes's notice order; Judge Kenney dismisses DOJ preemption claims against Philadelphia's ICE detainer law; Addleshaw Goddard goes firmwide on Harvey and WongPartnership picks August.
Better Call Claude Briefing — Nov 9, 2026
The Supreme Court opens its week with two arguments that test how far people can go to hold the government and private condemnors to account: a Bivens suit over a federal prisoner's untreated injury and a pipeline case asking whether landowners can recover their attorney's fees. Over the weekend, a deportation flight bound for Iran was scrapped on an Arizona tarmac as lawyers accused the government of skirting a federal judge's notice order, and a Trump-appointed judge in Philadelphia threw out the Justice Department's attack on the city's ICE detainer law. In legal tech, Addleshaw Goddard committed to Harvey for its whole workforce and WongPartnership picked August to build custom AI. General news roundup only — not legal advice.
Supreme Court hears Bivens and pipeline-fee cases, adds bankruptcy-arbitration fight
On Monday, Nov. 9, the justices hear Nielsen v. Watanabe, brought by Hawaii man Kekai Watanabe, who says a federal prison paramedic, Francis Nielsen, gave him only over-the-counter pain medication after he was badly hurt in a fight at a federal detention center, and that he then spent more than two months in solitary without seeing a specialist. An x-ray seven months later showed a fractured coccyx with bone chips in the surrounding tissue. The Ninth Circuit let his damages claim go forward under Bivens, the 1971 decision that first allowed suits against federal officers for constitutional violations. Nielsen and the Trump administration, as a friend of the court, want the case shut down, and Nielsen asks the Court to go further and foreclose such claims more broadly. The Court has extended Bivens only twice, most relevantly in Carlson v. Green, a prison medical-care case. The second argument, Hoffmann v. WBI Energy Transmission, asks whether North Dakota ranchers whose land was taken for a gas pipeline under the Natural Gas Act can recover roughly $383,000 in attorney's fees and costs under state law. The Eighth Circuit said no, treating the private pipeline company like the federal government, which owes only Fifth Amendment market value; other circuits have let state fee rules apply. On Friday the Court also agreed to hear Goldman Sachs Bank USA v. Brown, on when a bankruptcy court can refuse to enforce an arbitration agreement. Why it matters: Watanabe could all but close the door on damages suits against federal officers, and Hoffmann will set the price tag for pipeline condemnations nationwide.
Sources: SCOTUSblog (Watanabe preview), SCOTUSblog (Hoffmann preview), SCOTUSblog (week ahead and Goldman grant), Dorsey & Whitney analysis, InForum
Deportation flight to Iran scrapped as lawyers allege breach of Judge Reyes's order
Late Saturday, Nov. 7, the Iranian American Legal Defense Fund told U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes in Washington, D.C., that ICE planned to remove 11 Iranian nationals, ten men and one woman, at about 4 a.m. Sunday from Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, refueling in the country of Georgia and flying to Islamabad, Pakistan, with onward transfer to Iran on Nov. 10. The group said the detainees had been moved overnight from the Florence and Eloy detention centers and issued 15-day Pakistani transit visas, and that an Iranian government official met with detainees in Arizona on Friday. It filed what it called a notice of apparent violation of Reyes's Oct. 15 order, which requires 24 hours' notice of any finalized removal plan and five business days' written notice before anyone is put on a vehicle or plane bound for Iran or a coordinating third country; the group says the government's notice came only three business days earlier. On Sunday morning, after at least eight detainees were loaded onto the plane, the flight was canceled without explanation and the detainees were returned to detention, according to the group's attorney Ali Rahnama. DHS said it does not comment on prospective removal operations. The underlying suit alleges the government shared confidential asylum information with Iran; Reyes denied a preliminary injunction on Oct. 20 but kept the notice requirements and warned she would start contempt proceedings against anyone who violated them. Why it matters: removals to a country the U.S. is at war with raise acute danger for asylum seekers, and whether the government honored a court's notice order is now squarely before the judge.
Sources: AP News, ABC News, Anadolu Agency
Philadelphia wins dismissal of DOJ challenge to its ICE detainer law
On Thursday, Nov. 5, U.S. District Judge Chad F. Kenney, a Trump appointee in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, dismissed with prejudice the Justice Department's two preemption claims against Philadelphia Code Section 21-3706, one of seven "ICE Out" bills the City Council passed in April and Mayor Cherelle Parker signed in May. The law bars city agencies and employees from holding someone who is otherwise eligible for release based on an immigration detainer, an administrative warrant, or suspicion of an immigration violation. On express preemption, Kenney held the Third Circuit already decided in Ocean County Board of Commissioners (2021) that the federal information-sharing statutes do not preempt local laws like this one, and the government conceded that precedent binds. On conflict preemption, he relied on Galarza v. Szalczyk (2014), which held detainers are requests rather than commands; making ICE find people after release is "mere inconvenience," not an obstacle to federal enforcement. The rest of the suit, which targets the city's ban on masked federal officers, is still pending, so an immediate appeal would need a Rule 54(b) certification. Why it matters: a ruling from a Trump-appointed judge reinforces that cities can decline to hold people for ICE, even as the administration presses sanctuary-policy suits around the country.
Sources: Philly Rhino News
Legal tech: Addleshaw Goddard goes firmwide on Harvey; WongPartnership builds custom AI with August
London-headquartered Addleshaw Goddard announced on Nov. 9 that, starting in January, it will give Harvey to its entire workforce of more than 3,400 lawyers and business services staff across Europe, the Middle East and Asia. The choice followed a three-month assessment led by the firm's 80-person Innovation Group in which about 400 people tested competing platforms on real legal and business tasks. The deal includes ongoing co-development: Harvey's product team has already worked with the firm on Review Tables, improving source checking, preservation of lawyer-reviewed work, sharing, and performance for large matters. Innovation head Kerry Westland told Artificial Lawyer the firm wants to push features for large-scale projects, while its in-house AGPT platform may shift toward testing. In Singapore, WongPartnership said on Nov. 4 it chose New York-based August as a strategic AI partner to build configurable tools shaped by its own precedents and methods, on top of its existing Harvey deployment and a pilot of Thomson Reuters' CoCounsel. Why it matters: firms are no longer just buying licenses; they are negotiating co-development rights and running several AI vendors side by side, betting that firm-specific know-how is the edge.
Sources: Addleshaw Goddard, Artificial Lawyer, WongPartnership
Not legal advice
This Briefing is a general news summary from Better Call Claude (bettercallclaude.org) and is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For help with your situation, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
Source: SCOTUSblog, AP, ABC News, Philly Rhino News, Artificial Lawyer
Published automatically by an AI newsroom on bettercallclaude.org. General information only — not legal advice, and not a substitute for a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
